Renting to Family or Friends: Avoiding IRS Tax Issues
Be aware of the tax rules while renting property to family members
When it comes to renting to family or friends, as a property owner, there are a variety of issues to consider. Also, you need to be aware of the different tax implications and IRS Tax issues that come with renting to your family or friends, affecting your bottom line. Furthermore, this needs to be addressed before you get in hot water. The biggest issue is that the IRS has specific rules for renting to family or friends, including special rules and limitations. If you cut your family member or friend a deal, (renting below market value) the IRS can disallow your deductions and may even impose penalties if you do not follow the proper house rules for renting.
If you own a vacation home or rental property, it might be tempting to rent it out to a family member as an investment property for less than full price. Because you already know your family members, they may be wonderful tenants because they are more likely to be respectful of the property and to take good care of it, providing a sense of security. Renting it to a relative can be a great option as they are likely to take good care of the property and the care of your home. But too good of a deal will result in losing your ability to write off your expenses. Check our story on renting to family.
Some Disadvantages
There are, however, certain disadvantages to renting to family or friends, such as the possibility of negative tax consequences in some cases. It is possible that you may be required to declare your rental earnings as income. Additionally, you will not be allowed to deduct the costs of care of your property and maintenance from your tax liability. Avoiding tax issues can save you in the long run, which is why having a property manager can be an invaluable asset in these tricky situations.
Furthermore, if you don’t exercise caution, renting to a family may result in your home being classified as a personal use property rather than a rental property. If this happens, you will miss out on several important rental expense deductions, such as depreciation and other expenses like maintenance, association dues, and utilities, which are considered non-deductible personal expenses. Detailed information on these deductions and limits can be found in IRS Publication 527, Residential Rental Property, including deductions for mortgage interest.
Here’s what you need to do to prevent this situation:
Renting a house or apartment to your child, parent or relative who lives there as their main and personal residence is subject to fair market rent requirements. Therefore, when establishing a fair rental price, you might gather information from websites such as Craigslist where similar rentals are listed. With a rental assessment, you may also benefit from the assistance of an impartial appraiser or an experienced real estate agent to provide an independent appraisal and understand the impact on the value of your property. It is important to also perform a thorough background check, including income verification, credit requirements, and talking with prior landlords and checking references, before allowing anyone to sign a lease and move in. This process is crucial to avoiding potential IRS tax issues when renting to family or friends.
Give your relatives nothing that will make it easier for them to make their rent payments. However, helping them out by giving them any type of financial assistance may backfire since the net amount of rent charged (the rent minus the gift you earn) may be less than the fair market rent price, leaving the property subject to losing your ability to deduct the deductible expenses.
It is permissible to charge a relative a somewhat lower rent under the terms of the tax code’s good-tenant clause. Although a discount of up to 20% is permissible, tax experts normally recommend using a 10% reduction since it is safer for you to explain to the IRS.
Fair Market Rent
Even though you chance your relative fair-market rent, you may make the error of converting the property from a rental to a personal residence if your relative does not live in it as their principal residence. If you rent out your condo in Arizona to your siblings for two months while they maintain their primary residence in Michigan, the unit is regarded as a second home rather than a rental property under the IRS definition. However, it is important to understand the vacation home tax law. Under this law, if your property is rented out for the winter months and used as a vacation home at a fair price, it would not be classified as a rental property.
It’s important to evaluate how renting a second home or a vacation property may affect the capacity of other members of your family to rent the space for their own personal purposes for tax purposes. No matter how much you charge for rent, their utilization matches your usage. Their rental service consumption counts against the 14 days of tax-free rental service, or 10% of total rental days, that are available to you. However, as long as you are renting to family or friends and they pay a fair market rent for the property, all of your normal rental expenses will be tax deductible with no limitations.
Five things you must do…
In short, there are five things you must do to guarantee that you may continue to deduct rental property expenditures from your taxable income.
1- Set a fair-market rent and collect it.
2- Demonstrate that the rent you charge is market-rate.
3- If you’re renting to a relative, be sure it’s their primary house.
4- Don’t provide gifts to relatives to enable them to avoid paying fair-market rent.
5- If you’re going to give a good-tenant discount, make it a fair one, like 10%.
You can claim tax deductions for the rental property on your tax returns if you follow these guidelines.
When Renting to Your Children, What Expenses Can Be Deducted?
Renting to children is the same as renting to anybody else to obtain a tax break. When renting to your children, you may have income tax concerns that require you to deduct expenditures over income, but this is not due to the link. In terms of cost, it all depends on how much you charge for the privilege of working with youngsters. As for rent, start with the concept of “fair value” to understand of the potential threats which may exist in your circumstance.
Why Fair Value Is Important
According to the IRS, you can rent out your house to anybody, even your children. The IRS is looking for you to charge your children what the IRS regards to be “fair market value.” This should cause you concern as well since it is the only thing that matters to the IRS. If the amount is less than the market value, you may have a problem.
As a result of this, home rental income generates the ability to deduct expenditures that exceed rental revenue as a tax loss carry-forward. Secondly, the profit is accessible to individuals who make money from their rental properties. The IRS, on the other hand, considers renting below the market rate to be a not-for-profit enterprise, rather than a profit-making enterprise. Any expenses that exceed the income from rentals, including a depreciation deduction, are not able to be carried over to a subsequent year.
How This Works for your Tax Return
Consider, for example, the little cottage behind your house, which you decided to convert into a rental property. You decide to charge your daughter $250 a month for the use of the property to make ends meet. This equates to a $1,200 yearly cost for the service. The fair market rental price for the unit in its current condition is around $600 per month. You decide to go all out for your daughter and make her place the really nice.
Your renovations, on the other hand, cost you $40,000 in total. Tax deductions of $3000 in expenditures may be claimed in the year that you make the modifications, thereby removing the $3,000 in rental revenue that you would have received. Only $37,000 of it may not be deductible in future years, according to the IRS. Because the cottage was a not-for-profit rental at the time of the modifications, this applies even if your daughter moves out after a year or two and you re-rent the cottage at market rate once she does move out.
Some Work Arounds (That Don’t really Work)
According to IRS regulations, the maximum permitted gift value for 2024 is $18,000, so you would think that charging your daughter $1,350 a month for the updated property and then giving her $18,000 in the form of a gift would be a good idea for the tax year. In your letter, you expressly indicate that she has a total choice over how she spends the money. The $18,000 gift turns out to be around $20 cheaper per month than the market rent for a one-bedroom apartment in your neighborhood, even though the market rate is $1,350, for whatever reason. The fact that money is fungible means that you have no way of knowing whether the money she is using to pay you to rent is cash you gave her or money she received from another source of income.
If you’re contemplating tax evasion, you should be aware that you’re breaking the law. Avoid IRS Tax Issues can be easy if you follow these guidelines. If you are caught, you may not be charged with felony tax fraud. Most likely you will be required to pay all back taxes and interest related to the scam, as well as a significant penalty. The IRS will very certainly determine that the rental was not for profit, in which case you will not be able to deduct any remodeling costs that are more than the amount you received in rent from your tax return.
You may accomplish the same result by offering your children a larger-than-average rent cut in exchange for any work they do to enhance the flat. Maintaining thorough records is particularly vital if you’re paying a relative to do repairs on their rental property on your behalf.
A Few Rental Tips when Renting to Family or Friends
It is entirely appropriate to rent a property to a family, notwithstanding the preceding cautions. Because they are working with someone they trust, both gain from this arrangement as well. However, it is important to keep a clear perspective and not develop a false sense of security when renting to friends or family members. It is critical to treat them like any other prospective tenant and evaluate their financial stability and rental history objectively. It is also important to keep track of actual rental rates for comparable properties to determine the true market rate.
Family members may even be eligible for a small reduction of the “market rate,” according to the IRS. In one instance, the IRS granted a 20% “good tenant discount,” which did not jeopardize the organization’s for-profit status. To avoid getting into trouble with the IRS, it is recommended to offer a percent discount of no more than 10% relative rents, while still charging fair rental value. It is also important to maintain a professional relationship with your family or friends while renting to them, setting clear boundaries and expectations to avoid any conflicts or misunderstandings.
Renting to Friends can be tricky too.
A great way to to lose a friend is renting to them and them expecting special treatment and a lower rent amount. Legal issues aside, losing a close relationship over rental issues is not a positive experience for the property owner.
Tenant Screening Process for Renting to Family or Friends
When renting to friends and family, the tenant screening process must be approached with caution. Conduct thorough background checks, including credit requirements and prior landlord references. Despite personal relationships, it’s crucial to treat them professionally. Establish clear boundaries and communicate expectations upfront. Utilize market rent rates to set the appropriate rent amount. By screening friends and family as rigorously as any other tenant, you ensure a successful tenancy for both parties.
Alternatives to Renting to Family or Friends you may consider exploring property management companies for a professional approach to renting. This avenue ensures clear boundaries and a business-like transaction rather than a personal one. Additionally, market rent can be agreed upon, eliminating any need for special treatment. Opting for this strategy can prevent potential conflicts that may arise from renting to close relations. Furthermore, it provides a layer of security for both parties involved.
Professional Property Management for Family or Friends
It’s wise to consider professional property management when renting to family or friends. A property management company can help maintain a professional relationship by handling lease agreements, rent collection, property maintenance, and tenant screening. This ensures clear boundaries and minimizes conflicts. Additionally, it adds a layer of formality to the rental process, treating it more like a business transaction rather than a personal favor. By engaging a property management company, you can navigate potential pitfalls and protect both your property and relationships effectively.
Handling Eviction of Family Members
When faced with the difficult scenario of having to evict a family member from a rental property, it’s vital to handle the situation delicately. Setting clear boundaries from the beginning and having a formal rental agreement in place can help streamline the eviction process. Despite the personal relationship involved, treating the eviction as a business transaction is crucial for a smooth resolution. Communicate openly, adhere to the terms of the lease, and seek legal advice if needed to navigate this emotionally challenging situation effectively.
FAQs
Is it a good idea to renting to family or Friends?
Renting to family or friends can be a tricky situation. While it may seem convenient, there are potential risks to consider, such as strained relationships and blurred boundaries. It’s important to approach renting to family members with caution and clear communication to avoid potential conflicts or tax issues.
What are the potential advantages and disadvantages of renting to family?
Renting to family can have advantages such as easier communication and trust, but it can also have disadvantages. These include potential conflicts over rent or property maintenance, strain on personal relationships, and the risk of financial loss if family members fail to pay rent or damage the property.
Should there be a formal agreement or contract when renting to family or friends?
Yes, it is highly recommended to have a formal agreement or contract when renting to family members. This helps to establish clear expectations, terms, and responsibilities for both parties involved. It also provides legal protection and prevents potential conflicts or misunderstandings in the future.
How can you handle conflicts that may arise when you rent to family members?
Handling conflicts when renting to family members requires open and honest communication. Establish clear boundaries, expectations, and rules from the beginning to avoid misunderstandings. If conflicts do arise, address them promptly and respectfully to find a solution that works for everyone involved.
Are there any legal considerations or requirements that need to be taken into account when renting to family members?
Yes, renting to family members comes with legal considerations. It’s important to treat the transaction as a business arrangement to avoid potential IRS tax issues. Make sure to have a written lease agreement. Charge fair market rent, and maintain proper documentation to prove that the rental is legitimate.
Read More
